On arbitration projections and the Tigers rotation

One of the new traditions of the early offseason is the MLBTradeRumors list of projected arbitration figures, the end result of a process that has become more detailed over the years. It’s not always spot-on (it can’t be, really, when so many players and teams settle and avoid a hearing), but it’s usually a good estimate, and it definitely gives an idea of what to expect come arbitration time in January. It’s also helpful for payroll projection projections.

In the case of the Tigers rotation, the projections show a starting staff that’s about to get a major raise. This winter’s projections, released Tuesday, predict David Price to make $18.9 million next year (up from $14 million this past season) and Rick Porcello to make $12.2 mil (he made $8.5 mil this year).

That’s a $31.1 million combined bump salary. Add to that the contractual raises in the long-term deals for Justin Verlander (whose salary goes from $20 million this year to $28 million next) and Anibal Sanchez (from $15.8 million this year to $16.8 million in 2015), and the top four starters in the Tigers rotation would make a combined $75.9 million under the projections for Price and Porcello. The Cubs, Astros and Marlins all had lower team payrolls when the 2014 season began.

With that, you get an idea why the Tigers’ payroll is becoming a major issue, and why it would be very difficult to hold team payroll steady around $163 million next year, no matter what the Tigers do this offseason (even if they traded Price heading into his contract year).

The rest of the projections put J.D. Martinez in line to make $2.9 million in his first year of arbitration eligibility, and Al Alburquerque at $1.7 million in his second year (he made $838,000 this year). No projection was made for Alex Avila, who has a $5.4 million club option next year.


It isn’t a combined $31.1M bump. That’s their total salary. The bump is $9.7M if I’m doing my math correctly.

Fixed. But you get the point. $9.7 million uptick there + $8 million more to Verlander + $1 million raise to Sanchez.

Trading Kinsler would help to keep the payroll low for years. He was great until the ASG and becoming the popup leader in MLB. They need to keep Price or trade for someone like Hammels.
12.5? that means he would make 15.5 as FA. That is a lot for a 4.30 ERA

MLBTR did make a prediction for Avila – he’s predicted to make $5.4 in arbitration, it just so happens to also be the amount of his option.

Pingback: Tigers could have $80 million rotation even without Max Scherzer | HardballTalk

I like Kinsler but would not miss him with all the popping up. It got old. Could better use the money elsewhere. Are there teams that would pick up his salary? JD (2.9 mil), in light of those pitching contracts, and considering his offensive contributions, is a loud disparity.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s