Quotes on Iglesias deal
Comerica Park was just about empty except for the press box and the front offices by the time the Jose Iglesias trade was announced right around midnight. Most of the media had stuck around hoping there would be some sort of official acknowledgement after rumors for just about an hour.
There was an acknowledgement, all right — not just of the trade, but of the concerns about Jhonny Peralta’s status that led to it. After withholding comment on Major League Baseball’s investigation into the Biogenesis scandal for weeks, Dombrowski — while not wanting to comment on the case — commented on the uncertainty it created to their postseason hopes and the reactions they’ve been having to the news reports about potential suspensions and the chances for an appeal.
“There’s a lot of uncertainty facing the situation which concerned me, especially with our scenario trying to win a championship,” Dombrowski said. “I don’t really know what’s going to happen as far as timing is concerned, but I also think that when there are enough things being discussed, you get a little concerned about those things.
“My problem ends up being that after 4 o’clock tomorrow, I cannot aggressively try to do anything that’s assured. Because after 4 o’clock, if anything happens, and people know we’re looking for a shortstop, there are shortstops that aren’t going to make it through waivers. So it contributes, but we wouldn’t have made a deal that we weren’t comfortable making to this magnitude unless this type of player was involved coming back.
“We’ve had some other people throw some names at shortstop for us that we didn’t see fitting in for us. Maybe they were a short-term solution but not a long-term solution and asking for the same caliber of player. We were not interested in that. It just did not make sense. But we have always thought at some point that we may have to trade one of our young outfielders for another hole that we would have for the future. And so, there were a lot of contributing factors here, but the biggest thing was we got a real good player that we think could play for us a real long time.”
One more telling quote on the investigation:
“I do think there are some things are going to take place,” Dombrowski said, “but what is going to take place, I’m not 100 percent sure.”
More quotes from Dombrowski on how the deal went down:
“We had some contact that went nowhere really this morning around 11 o’ clock and then we started around 2 o’ clock just another something. Then around 3 o’clock, we were not really anywhere seriously discussing things. It didn’t really start taking place until close to game time. You know they are deep at shortstop, they got Drew at short now, they got Iglesias, who they like, they have Bogaerts coming. And so for them they are deeper there, they are one of the clubs that we looked at for the future, at the end of the year, when Jhonny did become a free agent that we kind of identified that could have some depth at shortstop.
“They asked us about a couple other players that we weren’t willing to do, not that we wanted to give up Garcia, but it came along pretty quickly. And Ben was open, as we got to that closer to game time, saying this would be a three-way deal, and would I have a problem with that. And I said basically, I don’t want to see Avisail Garcia play against us 18, 19 times a year for the next 10 years, but if we also come up with a real good player at shortstop, and we’re deeper in outfield, which we are. We still have Castellanos down at Triple-A, [Tyler] Collins and [Daniel] Fields. And we think that we’re getting a real good player, and we traded a real good young player for another real good young player but at a position that which we need right now or potentially could need, and I know that we’ll need next year.”
On trading a very good prospect to a division rival:
“I’ve never been hesitant with that. That doesn’t phase me. And I fully expect Garcia to be a really good player. I don’t really want to watch him play 18 times a year, and I’m sure he’s going to beat us at some times during that time period, and there will times when people say that Dombrowski was not very smart when he does that. But I think it’s more important about the player that you get in return. As long as we get a player that helps us at the same time be a real good player, then that’s what you can get, I hope it helps everybody.”
Dombrowski did say that the Red Sox asked them for another player earlier in talks that he was not prepared to give up. It’s not clear whether or not that might have been Nick Castellanos, or if the Tigers had to choose one or the other to trade. The quote near the top seemed to hint towards that.
Another quote later in the session strongly hinted that the Tigers are not going to mortgage the future to win this year, a quote that some might have suspected but needed to hear someone in the organization say:
“I think for us as you look forward, you look where you have holes, where you have potential free agents, and where you can cover yourself. Without getting into where we are next year, we know we have a free agent at second base, a free agent at shortstop and some free agents in the bullpen, and all of a sudden where I wasn’t so sure where we’d be going with that. I think we’re in a spot where our goal is not only to be good this year and the last couple of years, but to continue to be good for years to come. And I think that this is a situation that all of a sudden if you do lose some players, we’ve got some good young guys that can help us fill those spots and are ready to play right now, just like Castellanos. I think he’ll be ready next year to play. Will he play? I don’t know, because I don’t know how the club will come together. But all of a sudden you start talking about guys such as Perez, Iglesias, Castellanos and Rondon, who we talked about, that’s a pretty good group of young guys that you can complement with some of the veteran players that we know who will be with us that are in the prime of their careers.”
On Peralta’s status:
“Peralta is our shortstop unless he’s ruled not our shortstop. When I talked to Jose, his agent [Fern Cuza, who is also Miguel Cabrera’s agent] happened to be there with him, and he asked him how much playing time is going to get. Will he be playing everyday? And right now, I can’t answer that question. I don’t really know. We think he will be a very valuable part of our club, we think he’ll be a very valuable part as we go in the long-term. But right now, Peralta is our shortstop, and we’ll just see happens. The value with him also is he can play third, he can play second very well too.”
On whether Biogenesis investigation rushed them into a deal:
“I don’t feel rushed into the decision. It’s not like we’re sitting back there without all of our reports being read and being thoroughly looked at. In fact, we sat down today with [pro scouting director] Scott Bream, Scott Reid, Al Avila and Mike Smith and we figured out all of the young shortstops that Scott Bream would be looking at in the month of August from our list, and there weren’t very many of them. And we didn’t even worry about seeing Iglesias, because we knew Iglesias would fit into that position already. So that’s how highly we think of him.
“We have always thought, at some point, we were probably going to have to do something there. I didn’t want to have to do that for a guy who is here for two months, but a guy who can play shortstop for the next half dozen years here. That’s a very valuable person that we gave up a very valuable player to get.”