Could Freddy return to Detroit? Maybe, but not likely

The Tigers helped get Freddy Garcia back on the mound a few years ago after shoulder surgery, then watched him help thwart their division hopes with the White Sox the following season. Now that Garcia is a free agent again and the Tigers need some starting competition, would a reunion in Detroit be possible, or has he burned his bridges here?

It’s possible, though unlikely at this point. Tigers officials at least pondered the idea this offseason, and Garcia is believed to be open to it. But all indications point towards Brad Penny and Jeremy Bonderman getting more consideration from the Tigers right now as they look for a veteran starter to push Armando Galarraga for the fifth starter spot.

On the list of back-end starting options, the Tigers certainly could do worse.

Garcia went 1-1 with a 4.20 ERA in three starts down the stretch for Detroit in 2008 after missing more than a year rehabbing from labrum surgery. More shoulder trouble in winter ball helped keep the Tigers off him that offseason. He rejoined the White Sox, where he helped win a World Series in 2005, and went 15-10 in Chicago over the last two seasons, but with a 4.56 ERA and 27 home runs allowed over 213 combined innings.

Garcia throws with even less velocity now than he had a few years ago, but he gets more results out of less pure stuff than a lot of pitchers in his situation. As one scout put it, he pitches like he can throw 95 mph. He also has as much experience with AL Central hitters as anyone on the market — 36 plate appearances against Justin Morneau (6-for-29), 35 PAs versus Joe Mauer (13-for-31), 36 with Travis Hafner (15-for-33) and 34 against Jim Thome (5-for-23).

There’s also the 18-7 record he sports against the Tigers, including 2-1 with a 4.39 ERA in five meetings with Detroit last year. His seven innings of one-run ball with seven strikeouts at Detroit on the final Saturday of the 2009 season was a major blow in the Tigers’ division collapse, dropping them into a tie with the Twins.


When the Tigers signed him to a minor league deal, I wondered why they let him go, frankly. He was always a Tiger killer against us.
He’d have to reassure me and probably alot of fans that his friendship with Miggy would remain on the field and not trickle over to the nightlife, if you get my gyst.

Garcia, Penny, and Bonderman are all RHP. If they can win 1/2 of their games as a 5th starter, it would help. I still think the team needs another LH starter. I thought DeLaRosa would be good but he signed elsewhere. Is that Jeff Francis still on the market? Another thing to consider is a long relief pitcher. Every starter is not going to last 6-7 innings every game. Who best fits that role now? Not Zumaya, I hope. Brad Thomas? If the Tigers do sign Penny or Bonderman and Coke and Galarraga do fine as starters,they would have some experience to fill the long relief role. I’ve lost count of how many pitchers are available for relief pitching. Is there room to logically add one more?

“Maybe but not likely” kind of puts this into a discussion-only phase, but that’s cool. Garcia seems to have a knack for taking advantage of hitters’ stupidity, for lack of a better term. He excels against the Tigers, so take that as you will. I have no problem with bringing him to ST, but I think our real options are better found elsewhere. I do like Freddy.
I’m not sure if Galarraga is the kind of guy who responds to being “pushed.”
Long relief; try this theory on for size: if one is needed, it’s usually because the starter got knocked around. By the time the long man comes in, the opposing hitters have relaxed and become prone to giving their ABs away. As long as you don’t walk people, your odds of success are enhanced in the long man role. That doesn’t mean anyone can do it, but a guy with a little stamina and control can get it done. Feel free to shoot this theory to pieces. It’s all in fun on a cold winter’s day.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s