Tigers adjust to the market on Joaquin Benoit

Dave Dombrowski has never been an outspoken flagbearer for general managers who don’t like overpaying for setup relief. In light of his pending three-year deal contract with Joaquin Benoit, that’s probably a good thing.

Still, Dombrowski’s track record speaks for itself. In his first nine seasons as Tigers general manager, he never signed a non-closing free agent reliever to a multi-year deal. Detroit signed Danny Patterson to a three-year, $7 million extension in January 2002, but that’s generally regarded as a Randy Smith contract, before Dombrowski took over as GM but after he had come in as team president/CEO. That deal went bad in less than six months, when he underwent elbow surgery. Total appearances Patterson made in those three years: 62, two more than he made in 2001 before signing the deal. Detroit also signed Fernando Rodney to a two-year deal a few years ago, but that was to avoid arbitration.

After the Tigers’ World Series run in 2006, they watched left-hander Jamie Walker leave for a three-year, $12 million contract and replaced him with Bobby Seay. They never offered Fernando Rodney more than a one-year deal last winter before he left for the Angels and a two-year, $11 million contract. They were willing to discuss a two-year contract with Brandon Lyon, but didn’t come anywhere close to the three-year, $15 million deal he signed with Houston.

Dombrowski never railed against those deals, never talked about the dangers of it. He simply stated it was further than the Tigers were willing to go.

“He got a three-year deal, and we’re very happy for him,” Dombrowski said of Lyon’s deal at last year’s Winter Meetings. “We liked him, but we weren’t prepared to do that.”

The thought process, what goes unsaid, was that those deals weren’t a good investment for them, not for seventh- and eighth-inning guys. There were too much changeover from year to year to do that.

The Tigers did everything they could to try to avoid having to go there. They stuck to their guns on not giving Lyon a multi-year contract when they first signed him two years ago. They went big on relief arms in the 2008 Draft, topped by first-round pick Ryan Perry. They added Phil Coke and Daniel Schlereth in their big trade last winter.

Now, the Tigers are going that far and then some — at least a half-million dollars more on average per season than what Lyon got — to sign Benoit. The fact that they’re going there says what kind of year it was for the Tigers bullpen.

Joel Zumaya fired away with his 100 mph fastball and mowed down hitters for half a season before suffering another catastrophic arm injury. Perry never really showed the progression the Tigers hoped to see in his second Major League season. Bobby Seay, Zach Miner and prospect Cody Satterwhite had season-ending surgeries.

The result was Leyland saying the Tigers’ need for relief help was as big as their need for offense this offseason, and Dombrowski saying they could use a Brandon Lyon type of reliever. In a year when the Tigers have more payroll space to spend than any other season in recent memory, this has all the looks of an adjustment to the market.

But if you’re going to do it, you might as well do it for the best guy on the market. Benoit quietly dominated hitters in Tampa Bay with numbers that pop off the page. Add in the fact that he was coming off rotator cuff surgery that cost him all of 2009, and it’s nothing short of incredible.

Truth be told, I voted Benoit for AL Comeback Player of the Year over some far bigger names. The combination of the numbers he posted, the way he pitched and the injury he overcame was too good to avoid. Everybody I talked to — scouts, players and other officials — backed it up. This type of comeback just doesn’t happen. The fact that he came back this good, throwing in the mid-90s again, clearly convinced the Tigers — who had looked at him last winter — that he was worth the investment.

In a strange way, in fact, Benoit’s injury actually helped him on the market. Since he missed 2009, he didn’t have the numbers to qualify as a Type A free agent. So instead of having to give up a first-round pick to sign him, the Tigers don’t have to give up anything. Tampa Bay will get a supplemental pick for their trouble. The Type A free-agent relievers will most likely have to wait until the end of the month, when their former teams have to decide whether to offer them arbitration and set themselves up for the compensation draft pick.

I don’t know if Benoit will stay healthy by the end of the deal, when he’ll be 36 years old and a veteran of 12 Major League seasons. I’m sure the Tigers are serious enough about making sure he’s healthy and checking out his medical reports that it explains why they haven’t announced the deal yet. But if he’s healthy, even if he doesn’t dominate the way he did this year, he finally shores up the eighth inning for Detroit.

The Tigers adjusted to the market. Because while Benoit was going to get a long-term deal somewhere, Dombrowski and Leyland need results to get their contracts, too.


Jason, you’ve got all the bases covered!! “Comeback player of the year” and you were right on it.
His name kind of drifted off my radar and I wasn’t really thinking reliever out of the gate but it certainly was and hopefully will be a wise decision by Mr. Dombrowski. The amount of money to sign him doesn’t really bother me since, thankfully, the Tigers have that kind of money to work with, and we wanted to be sure and get the best before the best was taken by someone else.

The signing of Joaquin Benoit is historic, in a sense. This is the first free agent that DD has signed to a contract of more than two years since Ordonez before the 2005 season. After three consecutive seasons with no free agents signed to a multi year contract, we now have two in two years, both relief pitchers. Soon enough, we should be reading about DD’s first signing of a free agent non pitcher to a multi year contract in five years.

While DD has avoided free agency more than any other GM in the league in the past five seasons, he has always seemed to make an exception for closers. Urbina, Percival, Todd Jones twice, Brandon Lyon, and Valverde all were signed as free agents on a very short list. While it’s true that Lyon only signed for one season, he actually turned down a two year offer from the Twins for about the same money, because he wanted the chance to close, to pump up his value, and to get “closer money” a year later.

Lyon’s contract was for a bit less than Benoit’s, but Brandon was nowhere near the pitcher Joaquin was in the season before signing the contract. Benoit’s peripheral stats are stellar- a 1.34 ERA, yes, but a WHIP of 0.68, over 11 K per nine, 6 plus K/ BB, a homer every few months- just stellar. Almost unrepeatable.

The questionable part of this contract is the duration. Three years for a player of Benoit’s age and health history is expensive. The list of quality relievers is lengthy this winter. That’s a good thing, because the Tigers needed a set up man before they moved Coke to the pen. Now, they just need to replace Coke. Oh, and get a real starting pitcher.

This is a most excellent analysis of this transaction, Jason. Very good work, my man.
Am I the only one that thinks Coke can be a successful starter in the big leagues? My only concern was replacing him in the pen, and that’s being taken care of. He struggled at times with controlling his slider; at least I’m assuming that pitch that went every which direction was supposed to be a slider. As a starter, he’ll have multiple innings to make the adjustment on pitches he doesn’t initially carry out there with him. I don’t know, I think he can do this. He’s not being asked to be the ace, just a lefthanded 4 or 5 starter in the rotation. If it doesn’t work, he can always return to the pen. This is not like the Dontrelle business.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s