Casey starts again

In fact, it’s the same lineup as last night.

  1. Granderson, CF
  2. Polanco, 2B
  3. Sheffield, DH
  4. Ordonez, RF
  5. Guillen, SS
  6. Rodriguez, C
  7. Perez, LF
  8. Casey, 1B
  9. Inge, 3B

8 Comments

1st inning blues.
We saw the reason that Brandon will never win a Gold Glove. (Well let’s be real with that award you usually have to have offensive numbers too.)

He makes too many errors on balls that should be easy to handle. The DP ball he botched was symptomatic of when he has time to analyze what needs to be done at critical times. He often makes errors under these circumstances. If it is a reactionary type play athere is no one better at third–or chasing foul balls down the line and into the stands.

It’s the ones where he has time to out mental himself into a bad play.

Rogers should have been out of that inning and that inning would have been such a lift to get out of–until the ball was hit straight at Brandon.

This is the problem I have with him and you combine that with unproductive offense then you have to admit, he is expendable.

I like him–he’s a great guy, yada yada–but those are facts.

The Royals really give us a hard time don’t they?

5-1 Ugly, tonight and the magic number is down to 4–Yanks won in extra innings.
Hey guys don’t jump all over me for criticizing Inge. I defended him big time last year and do recognize the athleticism and personality.

You are what you are and Brandon is an average ballplayer.

15 hits 4 runs.

Granderson. Wow! 3 more doubles Bud and you are in unchartered territory.

Nice job by Maggs tonight. Season is over and he displayed some magical bat tonight and he deserves that title.

I hope Carlos can get his 100 RBIs but he is gonna have to turn things around.

We’re playin’ out the season now.

Ok,What about next year? Who agrees with me that we need a much bigger bat at first base? I mean, Casey is ok, but where is the homerun production usually associated with 1B?
Can we move Carlos to 1st and find ****? I realize that this year’s problems were injuries, especially to the pitching staff, but assuming that comes back, can we count on the old guys much longer? I mean Rogers and Sheff are getting pretty long in the tooth, not to mention Pudge. If A-Rod decides to ditch NY, is there any chance of him coming to Detroit? What do you think?

I won’t jump on you, Dan. In fact, the first thing I thought when Inge bobbled the ball was “Uh oh, Dan’s gonna trade him again.” :-)

Actually, I don’t see where that play was a mental error. He booted it, just like thousands or millions of balls have been booted over the long history of the game.

The big mental error of the game was Timo making the first out of the inning at thirdbase. Baseball 101, failing grade. This was punctated by Casey’s following single that would have scored Timo, making it 5-4 and changing the entire complexion of the game. That’s the third dumb baserunning mistake I’ve seen in the last four games. What’s up with that?

You want bad fielding, I’ll nominate Hill of Toronto. He tried his best to blow it last night and finally succeeded today. That was a whale of a slugging match they had in NY this afternoon, but after the Yankees won, tonight’s game meant little, as far as postseason aspirations are concerned. Again, pressure couldn’t be applied to the front runner.

Watson, while it’s true we need a big homerun bat, it doesn’t necessarily have to come at the firstbase position. If the big bat was a leftfielder, we’d be fine with that Casey/Guillen/Santiago triumverate at first and short. The big bat can also be a thirdbaseman, and that leads to talk of A-Rod. I’d like to have him, who wouldn’t, but personally I see him back in New York next season.

I will say that Dombrowski is going to get a stick this offseason. Don’t know who or from where, but it’s his MO. We’ll probably stick with the same pitchers, unless one goes in the trade for the big bat.

I’m not surprised that you have a 180 degree opinion on that Rich. That error probably cost the game today. Does it matter in context of the season? no. But it does matter.
Brandon has been prone to these type of errors since I started watching the Tigers again at the end of 2005.

When he is in a pressure situation and he has too much time to deliberate about what needs to be done with the ball he panics. Not all the time but often enough to impact a ballgame. This is not my imagination or my ornery personality. He makes those types of errors. Period.

Do I want to trade him–not really. Are there better third basemen around? Plenty.

Do we grin and bear it? Probably.

Same with Pudge. I think if you decide to go with these 2 guys at their positions again next year the results will be similar if not worse. Particulary from Pudge. Inge can’t get much worse offensively. Pudge can, and will.

His base hits are mostly innocuous. He bats 6th in a what some folks call a powerhouse offense with 5 guys who reach base often up before him. He has 63 RBIs. That’s not a whole lot more than Monroe had for us and he has been gone awhile and having a brutal year himself.

Keep him if you will but don’t bat him 6th. He is an 8th place hitter now. (Unless you have a couple of .230 hitters in your lineup.)

I just don’t go along with all the pretense about this club being OK the way it stands now. It’s OK if you are willing to be in 2nd or 3rd and play golf in October but it is not if you fully intend to win the whole thing.

The Tigers are close to this but they have had 2 years now to test run this vehicle and get the quirks fixed. That’s the job mangement has to do now. The players have done theirs. Alas, to the best of their abilities.

Pudge, yeah that reminds me. He really should have caught that throw from Timo and tagged the guy out at home. His defense isn’t what it once was either. That’s a tough call for management. I’m assuming he comes back. Not sure if that’s good or bad.

You will notice that I included thirdbase as a position where a big bat could be added. I’m not beyond agreeing with a change there. I do think that Inge makes the same kinds of errors that all thirdbasemen make. If that’s pressure, too much time to deliberate, or panic, I have no idea. Most of my errors at the thirdbase position resulted from bad throws on account of a lack of talent. :-)

it’s easy to jump on guys for striking out or for making errors

Team Building wins games though and that takes talent.

I’m gonn b e looking forward to what DD and JL have in mind over the off-season!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

Gravatar
WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 28 other followers